verified Achieved

Justice Justice

Consider the abolition of the not proven verdict as part of the prosecution review

Last updated 5 years ago

We will undertake a review of Scotland’s prosecution system… including - in recognition of the strong case that can be made for abolition - a consultation on the removal of the not-proven verdict...

SNP Manifesto 2021, p.61

Our verdict

Status

This promise was fulfilled in December 2021 when the consultation on Scotland’s three verdict system was launched. A consultation analysis was released in July 2022. These actions represent fulfilment of the pledge since it was limited in scope to reviewing and consulting on the verdict.

“Not proven consultation opens” (Scottish Government, 13th December 2021)

“Not Proven Consultation: independent analysis and responses published” (Scottish Government, 12th July 2022)